Today, I made one of my eighth-grade boys cry.
He was listening to the radio in class. I asked him to turn it off several times but, I’d turn my back a moment and it’d be on again. Arabic pop music on a cell phone, with the boys of that table crowded around. When I saw that they had fewer than three lines of writing on each of their journal pages, I snapped. (They were supposed to have had a page done by then.)
“Please step outside, Abdelrahman.”
The straight- and brown-haired boy took a few steps towards the door, then stopped hesitantly and raised his eyebrows at me as if to say, “Do I have to? Like really really?”
Yes, really really, I thought. “Wait outside ’til I call you back. Two minutes.”
Class went on. We started a collective story-writing activity. The story we came up with was about a boy who ventures out into the forest with his friend Akram on a moonlit night, only to be transformed upon being bitten by a wolf into a wolf, bearing a silver pendant. The friend-turned-wolf defends Akram against the rest of the pack and is dangerously wounded. Akram then searches for the flower embossed on the silver pendant and uses it to nurse his friend to health (and, magically, to humanity).
As this whole midsummer night’s dream unfolded, Abdelrahman stood outside, like a model on a magazine cover, with legs loosely crossed, arms folded against his chest, leaning proudly and a little indignantly against the wall. That’s what I saw anyway when one of his friends reminded me of him. My two-minute sentence had turned into a fifteen-minute purgatory. I don’t know which hurt him more, the humiliation of being out there for so long or the sense of being utterly and inconsolably forgotten.
Not surprisingly, when I invited him back in, he shook his head ever so slightly and shrugged his eyebrows as if to say “there’s no use.” Although I knew that I owed him a few minutes of persuasion-time, so that he could come back to class with a few shards of dignity, I couldn’t leave the class to be with him, so I didn’t press him further.
One of the boys offered to cajole him but returned, to my distress, without Abdelrahman. Another boy said he’d give it a try. He was successful.
Moments later, there was a ruckus on that table again. The boys were crowded around Abdelrahman. This time, it wasn’t to listen to music, but to comfort him.
“Miss! Miss! He’s crying.”
But Miss! Miss! didn’t know what to do.
I grew up believing that there are two ways to reconcile yourself to a crying child. The first is called the Mama Method. This one involves physical, verbal and psychological expressions of compassion. The second is called the Baba Method. It’s a silent but powerful hug that magically makes you feel safe and right again.
I did neither. I stood anxiously by as his friends teased him, patted his back and squeezed their heads together as if in a huddle. One boy sarcastically quoted a famous Arabic poem of praise, “Rajulun warrijalu qaleelu. A man, and men are few.”
Although Abdulrahman’s head was buried in his arms, I could see that he was now laughing. I was relieved.
As he left for break, I waved him over, but he either didn’t see me or pretended not to. I think he expected me to chastise him further because, when I spoke to him at the start of class, he seemed startled that I apologized.
“Do you forgive me?”
His hand froze in the bag of potato chips. He smiled a toothy smile, looked bashfully down, nodded like a happy puppy and went on munching.
My professors at UJ often joke that their students are present in body but not in mind. Today, I became the teacher whose absentmindedness literally made her student disappear. Lucky for me, that magic trick was not irreversible.